← Back to News
Should England have had a penalty for challenge on Kane?
WC 2026
B
BBC Sport·in about 4 hours

Should England have had a penalty for challenge on Kane?

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser. This video can not be played

Should England have been awarded a penalty?

As Harry Kane fell in the box, it looked like England were about to have the perfect opportunity to draw level against DR Congo late in the first half of their last-32 tie.

The Three Lions captain was played through on goal, knocked the ball past on-rushing goalkeeper Lionel Mpasi and ended up sprawled on the ground.

There was certainly contact and Kane was adamant he should have had a penalty, but referee Adham Makhadmeh waved away England's appeals.

The Jordanian official gestured the striker had dived, but did not show him a yellow card for the offence.

After a check from the video assistant referee (VAR), the on-field decision was upheld and England remained a goal behind at half-time, following a seventh-minute strike from Brian Cipenga - although Kane struck twice in the second half.

"This is so difficult," former Premier League assistant referee Darren Cann told BBC One.

"There are four of us here, two think it's a penalty, two think it's not a penalty and therefore it's not clear and obvious in terms of VAR.

"From live play it looks a penalty, a small touch on Harry Kane's ankle from the goalkeeper and he would be expecting to give away a penalty.

"From the referee's angle, Kane puts his two feet together, he stumbles and it doesn't look as much of a penalty. There-in lies the difference. For me, I think it's a penalty.

"The referee's decision would stand if he had given a penalty, the VAR would not have intervened."

As Cann mentioned, the pundits in the BBC TV studio were split on whether a spot-kick should have been awarded with former England striker Wayne Rooney not convinced Kane was fouled.

"I'm all for the forwards, but I think Harry Kane trips himself a bit and jumps into the goalkeeper a little bit," he said.

"I think it looks like he has dived into him, so it probably isn't a penalty."

However, the ex-Manchester United man was in the minority.

"If it's on my water bottle, I am working out where Kane's next penalty is going to be," former England keeper Joe Hart told BBC One.

"Mpasi will be delighted to when he looks up and sees the referee not giving it, because I would expect that to be given against me."

Former Manchester City defender Micah Richards added: "I just think Lionel Mpasi touches Harry Kane, so I want that as a penalty."

The pundits on BBC Radio 5 Live believe Kane did create the contact but were in agreement it was a foul by Mpasi.

"Definite penalty," added former Lionesses captain Steph Houghton. "I think even though Kane has initiated the contact, where else is he supposed to go when Mpasi comes out that quick?

"I'm so shocked the VAR didn't overturn the decision to be honest."

Ex-goalkeeper Paul Robinson, who played for England at the 2006 World Cup, said: "If England are to lose then there will be a question asked for a long time because it's a stonewall penalty.

"Harry Kane initiates the contact but the contact is there. He's very clever, very experienced and he goes into the goalkeeper."

Sorry, this vote cannot be loaded. In order to vote you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.

How to watch the World Cup on the BBC and ITV

Everything you need to know about the World Cup

Sources: BBC Sport

Get WC 2026 Updates

Match previews, results, and standings — delivered to your inbox.

Related Articles

'Wonderful finish' - Cipenga gives DR Congo shock lead against England
WC 2026

'Wonderful finish' - Cipenga gives DR Congo shock lead against England

Brian Cipenga gives DR Congo an early lead against England during their World Cup last-32 match in Atlanta.

B
BBC Sport·in about 4 hours
Brilliant Kane hits late double to save England
WC 2026

Brilliant Kane hits late double to save England

England goals: Harry Kane (75, 86) Congo DR goals: Brian Cipenga (7)

F
FIFA Official·in about 4 hours
Kane keeps England's World Cup dream alive as DR Congo beaten
WC 2026

Kane keeps England's World Cup dream alive as DR Congo beaten

Harry Kane scored a brilliant double to inspire England to a come-from-behind 2-1 win over DR Congo and set up a World Cup last-16 showdown with co-hosts Mexico.

S
Sky Sports·in about 4 hours
Why Mexico could provide a HUGE UPSET against England!
WC 2026

Why Mexico could provide a HUGE UPSET against England!

X Facebook TikTok Instagram YouTube WhatsApp Partners Sky Bet Super 6 TEAMtalk.com Football365.com Sky Sports Channels Sky Sports Main Event Sky Sports Premier League Sky Sports Football Sky Sports Cricket Sky Sports Golf Sky Sports F1 Sky Sports Ten

S
Sky Sports·in about 4 hours
England's route to World Cup final: Now for the early start against Mexico
WC 2026

England's route to World Cup final: Now for the early start against Mexico

What is England's potential path to World Cup glory?

S
Sky Sports·in about 4 hours
Mo Salah stands in Socceroos’ World Cup path as he strives to become Egypt’s greatest | Jack Snape
WC 2026

Mo Salah stands in Socceroos’ World Cup path as he strives to become Egypt’s greatest | Jack Snape

Despite a softening of his cutting edge and an international career defined by near misses, the forward is expected to cause problems for Australia It was fitting that it was Mo Salah who scored to put Egypt ahead in their World Cup match against New

T
The Guardian·about 20 hours ago