← Back to News
How do you stop Messi, Mbappe, Haaland and Kane?
Players
B
BBC Sport·about 10 hours ago

How do you stop Messi, Mbappe, Haaland and Kane?

Image caption, Four of the most in-form strikers in world football will look to add to their red-hot starts to the World Cup this week

Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Four of the most in-form strikers in world football will look to add to their red-hot starts to the World Cup this week

Football issues correspondent Published 4 minutes ago A World Cup is always that little bit more special when the game's star names come to the party.

And last week four of football's elite strikers announced their arrival in devastating fashion.

It was as though each was spurred on by the performance of the others.

Paris St-Germain's Kylian Mbappe got the ball rolling by scoring twice in France's 3-1 win over Senegal.

That was emulated a couple of hours later by Manchester City's Erling Haaland in Norway's 4-1 win over Iraq.

Then step forward Lionel Messi, the Inter Miami attacker proving his enduring class with a hat-trick as Argentina beat Algeria 3-0.

Bayern Munich's Harry Kane then netted twice as England beat Croatia 4-2.

Could this be the tournament of the star striker? And if you're up against them, how do you plan to stop them?

Four very different players, with contrasting styles but who are equally effective.

Former Everton and Wales defender Ashley Williams told BBC Sport how you might defend against them.

Image caption, Lionel Messi has scored 120 goals in 200 games for Argentina

Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Lionel Messi has scored 120 goals in 200 games for Argentina

Messi turns 39 on Wednesday, but you would not know it from his performance against Algeria.

The forward's treble took him level with Germany's Miroslav Klose as the World Cup's all-time top scorer on 16 goals - though Mbappe is just two behind.

With Messi on this kind of form, and on 120 international goals, how do you halt him in his tracks?

"It's more of a team effort," Williams said. "I always felt being a defender that you are hoping for a bit of luck.

"You've got to cover all your bases, which might be getting tight as a defender, or dropping off and letting your midfield get tight.

"Try as best you can to push him into comfortable areas with your body shape, your distancing and your angles of approach.

"He's one of those players where if you have to pick a poison, say you'd rather someone else take the shot than him."

Williams added that forcing an attacker onto their weaker foot would have limited success with Messi.

"He seems to take control in possession, no matter where you try to push him out to," Williams said.

"He's got the low centre of gravity, great balance, his touch is exceptional, so he can manipulate the ball and get you into a place you don't want."

Image caption, Kylian Mbappe scored a hat-trick in the 2022 World Cup final, which France lost on penalties to Argentina

Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Kylian Mbappe scored a hat-trick in the 2022 World Cup final, which France lost on penalties to Argentina

Williams has first-hand experience of Mbappe from his own playing days with Wales.

In November 2017, when Mbappe was a fresh-faced 18-year-old, Williams had to keep tabs on the striker for 84 minutes of an international friendly in Paris.

Mbappe did not score, but he did provide the assist for Olivier Giroud to complete a 2-0 victory.

By coincidence, the 27-year-old's brace against Senegal took him past Giroud to become France's all-time top scorer on 58 goals.

"He was very difficult to play against," Williams said.

"Mbappe is more direct than Messi. Not to say that he's better, but he's equally as hard to defend against.

"When Mbappe dribbles, it's normally with more pace. The way he will manoeuvre the ball to where he wants, in a twist and turn, is with more intensity.

"When you're playing against a striker that is normally 100 miles an hour, you stay in that rhythm as well. You're defending at that pace, whereas Messi will slow you down and then speed you up.

"I'd probably rather play against Mbappe, because you stay locked in with him."

France have such an array of world-class attacking talent, there is not just Mbappe to think about.

"You'll do your homework, and see what type of runs players like to make," Williams added.

"Michael Olise likes to come inside on his left foot a little bit more, which then might set off a run from Ousmane Dembele or Mbappe, so they will have trends that will be studied.

"If you focus all your attention on Mbappe, some of the others will hurt you.

"As a collective unit, you need to be working together on the same page."

Image caption, Erling Haaland's Norway will come up against Kylian Mbappe and France in the final group stage game

Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Erling Haaland's Norway will come up against Kylian Mbappe and France in the final group stage game

Haaland had to wait until the age of 25 not just to make his World Cup debut, but his international tournament bow too.

And the Leeds-born striker is clearly eager to make up for lost time.

"He's the opposite of Mbappe and Messi," Williams said. "He'll beat you without the ball, which makes it even more dangerous.

"You want to help your midfield by squeezing up, so they don't have to cover too much distance.

"But as soon as you leave the space in behind, he's going to exploit that straight away."

One of the keys to limiting Haaland's influence, Williams says, is to prevent his team mates getting the ball to him.

"You've got to stop the balls in behind first and foremost," Williams said. "Stop the supply going into him.

"If you can play your distances between your midfield and limit his chances, you've got half a chance.

"There's not many times when he actually drops in, gets the ball, beats four players, and scores his own goal, so he does feed off what he's getting served."

Haaland is the most clinical of the four, with 57 goals in just 51 caps.

"He's more lethal," Williams added. "If he gets a chance, it's probably going to be a goal."

What about dealing with Haaland one on one?

"Around the box, you've got to get tight and try to get him on his right foot," Williams said.

"Then you're just going to have to be as strong as you can, don't be clever, just get the ball away and buy time."

Image caption, Harry Kane scored twice against Croatia to take his tally for England to 81 goals in 115 caps

Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Harry Kane scored twice against Croatia to take his tally for England to 81 goals in 115 caps

Kane, 32, is no stranger to Williams, with the England captain having scored five goals for Tottenham against Williams' Swansea and Everton sides around 10 years ago.

But the Harry Kane of 2026 is a very different player to 2016.

"He was a little bit more mobile and bit quicker," Williams said. "He'd run in behind a bit more.

"Now he's not going to beat you in the dribble, so you've got to get up tight and not let him shoot.

"His shooting is arguably the best out of all these players."

Kane, now on 81 goals for England, shows real willingness to drop deep, and he can often be found near the halfway line or even in his own half.

"It's that element of Kane's game that sets him apart," Williams said.

"Against Croatia, he dropped into midfield a lot to use his qualities, his passing range.

"I'd stay in defence and communicate with midfield. As soon as he gets to a point, it would be their job to mark him, and I'd try to stay in a deeper position to cover the gap and beyond.

"I would be speaking to my defensive midfielder and saying 'I know you might be overloaded with your own man and Kane if he drops in, but we can live with that one'."

Kane's role presents a different challenge, allowing Noni Madueke, Jude Bellingham and Anthony Gordon to exploit the space.

"[The runners] would be the priority," Williams said. "It wouldn't necessarily be closing down Kane in midfield, especially from a defender's point of view.

"It's very difficult to play against a team that are going both ways. What we can't live with is if there's gaps in the back line and with runners in behind.

"From an England point of view I think that's probably their biggest weapon."

Play BBC Sport's new World Cup predictor game

Everything you need to know about the World Cup

Sources: BBC Sport

Get WC 2026 Updates

Match previews, results, and standings — delivered to your inbox.

Related Articles

Name the seven Scotland survivors from Clarke's first squad
Players

Name the seven Scotland survivors from Clarke's first squad

B
BBC Sport·about 10 hours ago
World Cup 2026: Cape Verde continue remarkable story; Messi, Mbappé and Haaland return – live
Players

World Cup 2026: Cape Verde continue remarkable story; Messi, Mbappé and Haaland return – live

⚽ All the latest news from day 11 of the tournament ⚽ Player guide | Bracketology | Golden Boot | Mail us Group G is pretty tight. Belgium, who ought to be favourites, are between teams, the old stagers not what they were and younger players not as g

T
The Guardian·about 10 hours ago
Cristiano Ronaldo risks ruining his legacy if he continues to stymie Portugal by starting | Miguel Dantas
Players

Cristiano Ronaldo risks ruining his legacy if he continues to stymie Portugal by starting | Miguel Dantas

At 41, Cristiano Ronaldo’s problem is not his age. It is that nobody seems willing to tell him to his face what everyone else can see. In Portugal, patience for the legend has run dry.

T
The Guardian·about 10 hours ago
Messi and Argentina ready to turn up the heat after fast World Cup start
Players

Messi and Argentina ready to turn up the heat after fast World Cup start

It is the 40th anniversary of Diego Maradona’s exploits against England. The scene is set for Lionel Messi to imbue the date with fresh significance How do you build on perfection? It is the poser Argentina face before a match that, for all its prosa

T
The Guardian·about 10 hours ago
2026 FIFA World Cup Golden Boot Race Tracker: David Joins Messi With Hat Trick
Players

2026 FIFA World Cup Golden Boot Race Tracker: David Joins Messi With Hat Trick

Follow the 2026 FIFA World Cup Golden Boot race with our live tracker, featuring the latest goalscoring standings, player statistics, and updates.

F
Fox Sports·about 10 hours ago
New Zealand v Egypt: World Cup 2026 – live
Players

New Zealand v Egypt: World Cup 2026 – live

⚽️ Kick-off time: 6pm local/11am AEST/2am BST/9pm EDT ⚽️ Player guide | Bracketology | Golden Boot | Mail Jonathan New Zealand arrived at this World Cup as rank outsiders but they are now 90 minutes from the knockouts. New Zealand, known as the All W

T
The Guardian·about 10 hours ago