← Back to News
Does it matter if Scotland lose and still make history?
History
B
BBC Sport·about 2 hours ago

Does it matter if Scotland lose and still make history?

Image caption, Steve Clarke and his squad are preparing for a potentially historic game

Image source, PA Media Image caption, Steve Clarke and his squad are preparing for a potentially historic game

BBC Scotland's chief sports writer Published 1 hour ago In a World Cup where the boffins with their big brainy heads and their super computers are working overtime on who might play who in the last 32, there are other calculations worth conjuring with.

As Steve Clarke's squad prepare to head for Miami to face Brazil on Wednesday, potentially the biggest day in the history of Scotland's national team, they travel having had no shot on target in their last game and a half and only two overall.

Che Adams, the principal striker, has had three touches of the ball in the opposition box in 146 minutes. One goal has been scored - a double deflection less than half an hour into the opening game.

Despite all their endeavour, all the heat they put on Morocco late on and a few big decisions that went against them, Scotland failed to register a shot on target on Friday, the first time that's happened to them on this stage since the 1986 World Cup.

They wanted to be a bazooka, but so far they're positively popgun. Taking the last Euros into account, Scotland have had five shots on target in their last five tournament matches. Their three goals across those five contests have come from two deflected shots and one own goal.

And yet, if the football data experts are to be believed, the chances of them progressing are high. The mad psychology is that win, lose, or draw, this might be the most glorious week in the long story of the national team, the moment they finally make it out of a group and into the nirvana of the knockout rounds.

Scots 'won't go gung-ho', but Naismith believes they can 'get job done'

Published 3 hours ago Scotland trio not part of training group

Published 5 hours ago Miami heat could mean a repeat of 1982 against Brazil - Vickery

Published 6 hours ago A first-ever win over Brazil would do the job beautifully. Cue a Tartan Army carnival in Miami to wipe the floor with anything that's seen in Rio.

A draw would spark the same merry chaos. The avoidance of defeat would need to be a hell of a Scotland performance, one that would merit a place in the last 32.

Where the mentality gets interesting and, perhaps to some, complicated, is if Scotland lose by a goal or two, or even three, and still make it into the next round. They could be utterly brilliant and progress and they could be utterly unthreatening and progress. They could play to keep the score down, pack the midfield, hoof everything downfield and never venture a shot on Brazil's goal and still make it through.

A strange kind of glory? Or, when you've lost out on goal difference so many times before, does it actually matter a damn?

Is the bottom line everything? Does the end justify the means? Never mind the quality, just rejoice in the qualification?

Would a win over Haiti followed by two defeats be acclaimed as a riotous success if it's enough to scrape into the knockouts as one of the best third-placed teams?

A point, or three, against Brazil and nobody needs to contemplate such existential issues. A result and Miami won't know what hit it, but they'll love it.

Clarke has been criticised in places for a supposed risk-averse approach against Morocco, a game that Scotland finished by having a forward line of Lyndon Dykes, Ross Stewart, Scott McTominay and Ben Gannon-Doak. If that was caution, it's hard to imagine what abandon looks like.

Clarke can't please some people, that much is obvious. No matter what he does, there is a constituency of fans out there that will slam him, some for legitimate reasons based on the paucity of the last Euros, many others because they just don't like the guy.

Calling on him to be gung-ho from the get-go against Morocco, or Brazil, is deeply flawed because that's exactly what those teams want Scotland to do.

Clarke is trying to find a balance that sits somewhere between ambition and pragmatism and hasn't really found it yet, but he's trying. Everybody's an expert in telling him what to do.

Steven Naismith, the assistant manager, spoke in Charlotte on Sunday about the fine line that Scotland had to walk against Morocco and will have to walk against Brazil, an infinitely more technically adept team with searing pace out wide and world-class finishers.

Scotland can try to go toe-to-toe with them in the manner of a middleweight taking on a heavyweight. There's only going to be one winner there.

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser. This video can not be played

'No bother' - Jack Hendry on facing Neymar

"If you look at Brazil in the last game [against Haiti] before half-time, it's 3-0," Naismith pointed out. "The game that's been on today [Spain led Saudi Arabia 3-0 after 24 minutes]... So there has to be a gameplan, but that doesn't mean we're sitting around in our 18-yard box for 90 minutes because taking into consideration the conditions and the opposition, it's impossible to do."

The heat in Miami will be oppressive, considerably hotter than Boston. Expecting Scotland to 'go for it' like mad dogs in a meathouse betrays a serious lack of understanding of the weather here.

"It's at moments in the game where we feel as if we're dominating, then we need to take risks and be ready," Naismith said. "But there's going to be hard moments where we need to set our shape and wait.

"Some of their players have got similar traits to Morocco's forward players. We'll go and do what we need to do to get through the group.

"That's ultimately what we're here to do. But we need to make sure we're solid because, as you've seen in some of the results, teams are ruthless when they get the opportunity.

"I sat here last week and said, if we qualify out of the group, it's the first squad to do it. I think this squad deserves to do it. I think we've got the players to do it and I think we've got the manager to do it.

"The magnitude of these games is definitely as [big] as any games [the players] have played in, but you know you can be punished at any one moment. You've got to be switched on."

Naismith talked about Scotland getting into the final third and then making poor decisions, which is a quality thing and, despite the reputations of some of these Scotland players they went up against more accomplished operators last Friday in Boston and they'll be doing the same again on Wednesday in Miami.

"When we've got possession, and we've got a good feel in the game that we're in control, we need to take risks to try and score," he said. "That's the bit that needs to change.

"We don't need to go, 'if we lose 4-0, we've still got a chance of going through'. We need to take the chances, definitely, but I'd rather have a proper gameplan than just going, let's go for it."

That's the essential weirdness of Scotland's situation. If they're trailing 1-0 late on, do they push, or do they settle? If they're trailing 2-0, do they commit more people forward or chase the game and run the risk of conceding more and taking themselves out of the tournament on goal difference in the process?

These are dilemmas you hope they don't have to face. Dan Marino, the greatest Miami Dolphin, once said of a player's mindset: "You have to feel you're the best at what you do. You don't have to come out and say it. But you have to know it within yourself."

Brazil will know it, that's for certain. Scotland need to believe it, too.

A game of football, but also a fascinating and complex game of psychology. What a denouement to the group this promises to be.

Everything you need to know about the World Cup

Sources: BBC Sport

Get WC 2026 Updates

Match previews, results, and standings — delivered to your inbox.

Related Articles

Youngest goalscorers in World Cup history
History

Youngest goalscorers in World Cup history

1st) Pele – 17 years & 239 days 2nd) Manuel Rosas – 18 years & 93 days 3rd) Gavi – 18 years & 110 days 4th) Ibrahim Mbaye – 18 years & 143 days 5th) Michael Owen – 18 years & 190 days 6th) Nicolae Kovacs – 18 years & 197 days 7th) Dmitri Sychev – 18

F
FIFA Official·about 2 hours ago
Japan break new ground on record-setting night
History

Japan break new ground on record-setting night

It was a landmark moment as Japan and Tunisia took to the pitch in the 1000th match in FIFA World Cup™ history. The game would prove significant not only for Japan, but for Asian football as a whole. As the Samurai Blue stormed to a , the team and th

F
FIFA Official·1 day ago
The World Cup records that look set to be broken
History

The World Cup records that look set to be broken

Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Lionel Messi has appeared at six World Cups, scoring 16 goals

B
BBC Sport·1 day ago
The brilliant Michael Olise represents a key faultline in history of French football | Jonathan Wilson
History

The brilliant Michael Olise represents a key faultline in history of French football | Jonathan Wilson

Unusually in the France side, he plays with a sense of freedom and has not yet submitted fully to Deschamps’s tactical yoke Michael Olisé is probably the best creative player in the world at the moment. He racked up 26 assists for Bayern Munich last

T
The Guardian·1 day ago
World Cup 2026: USA’s ‘high IQ’ squad backed to handle hype; Casemiro heading for Miami; Sweden’s Dutch test– live
History

World Cup 2026: USA’s ‘high IQ’ squad backed to handle hype; Casemiro heading for Miami; Sweden’s Dutch test– live

⚽ All the latest news from day nine of the tournament ⚽ Player guide | Bracketology | Golden Boot | Email us On this day in World Cup Euros history : 1976 – Antonin Panenka won the final for Czechoslovakia with the most famous penalty of all time. An

T
The Guardian·2 days ago
World Cup groups separated by head-to-head records for first time
History

World Cup groups separated by head-to-head records for first time

Image source, Getty Images Image caption, Mexico could choose to rest players against the Czech Republic with top spot secured

B
BBC Sport·2 days ago